
In 1964, well over 60 years ago, the U. S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of a theater owner who was showing the French film The Lovers, which had been deemed by the locals to be pornography.
Among the justices, Justice Potter Stewart voted to reverse the theater owner’s conviction, restricting obscenity laws to “hard-core pornography” and famously noting that while he couldn’t easily define it, “I know it when I see it.”
The same could be said of humor. It’s almost completely subjective. Even Saturday Night Live doesn’t always score a belly laugh, or barely rates a snicker. (In its early years, I thought SNL would be the death of comedy. All that most people were doing was repeating to each other the same jokes they heard the night before. Fortunately, I was wrong. Now there are many more popular sources to crib from. But I digress.)
I don’t know much about comedy theory, but, like Justice Potter Stewart, I know it when I see it, or in many cases, hear it.
But, as I said, comedy is subjective. So here’s my subjective opinion. Puns, often thought of as the dregs of humor, are hilarious. I may be prejudiced (in fact, I am), but I admire clever wordplay. Shaggy dog stories are the actual dregs of comedy. They make you wait too long for the payoff, which is often a pun or Spoonerism, but not a clever one.
I don’t mind humor featuring obscenities, because sometimes a bad word is exactly the right word. I also don’t mind religious humor. (I once told a joke featuring God and was confronted with a curt “That’s blasphemous,” in a tone that implied it was something bad. I didn’t stop telling jokes featuring God, just not to her. But I digress again.)
Written comedy is more difficult than just jokes. You have to maintain the tension that results in laughter for a distance or sprinkle smaller funny bits throughout while you build up to the payoff. My favorite short-form writers are David Sedaris and Jenny Lawson, while my favorite long-form writer is Christopher Moore, who wrote Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ’s Childhood Pal (speaking of blasphemy).
Mashups can be fun, too. The best one I ever saw was a readers’ theater production of “The Rocky Horror Muppet Show,” complete with song parodies. (Once I even dabbled in mashups myself, producing a short story mixing Star Trek and The Wizard of Oz. But I digress some more.)
What I do mind is comedy that “punches down,” or bases humor on laughing at marginalized groups like various races, ethnicities, sexes, or religions. (Once when a group of us were having an after-work drink, one of the guys told a disgustingly anti-woman joke. I threw money on the table to cover my drink, told him what I thought of his sense of humor, and stalked off. Two other women stood up and stalked with me. But I digress even more.)
I also don’t like comedy based in anger. This used to be fairly rare until Sam Kinnison became popular. Then other comedians jumped on the bandwagon, including George Carlin, whom I had previously revered for his gentle and hippie-dippie style and language-based routines. Lewis Black, with his acerbic, biting delivery, is the only one I can think of who really pulls it off.
So, what do I think is the funniest joke? Actually, I have two:
What did the Zen Buddhist say to the hot dog vendor? “Make me one with everything.”
and:
First old lady: My, it’s windy today.
Second old lady: No, it’s Thursday.
Third old lady: So am I. Let’s all go have a cup of tea.
My friend Beth likes one that’s a little raunchier:
A man walked into a clock shop. He went up to the counter, unzipped his fly, and laid his johnson on the counter.
“I’m afraid you’re mistaken,” the saleslady said, “This is a CLOCK shop.”
“Okay,” said the man. “Then could you put two hands and a face on it?”
My friend Tom prefers a riff on a childhood joke:
Why do elephants paint their toenails red?
So they can hide in cherry trees.
I’ve never seen elephants in cherry trees.
Works well, doesn’t it?
How about you? What’s your all-time favorite joke? If I get enough responses, I’ll feature them in a future post!
Discover more from But I Digress . . .
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.